The Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC) is seeking views to inform decisions on the introduction of regulations on minimum service levels (MSLs) in England, Scotland, and Wales, to protect patient safety in key hospital services during strike action.
The UK Government has already consulted on the application of minimum service levels for other sectors. In health, we want to strike the right balance between the ability of workers to strike and the protection of life and health. Our proposal is that most essential and time-critical hospital services should be covered by MSL regulations. This consultation will help to inform decisions on whether hospital services should be covered and, if so, which hospital services, the appropriate minimum service levels required, and whether any health services outside hospitals should be included.
The Strikes (Minimum Service Levels) Act 2023 applies to England, Scotland and Wales. The act does not apply to Northern Ireland.
The consultation period will run until 11:59pm on 11 December 2023.
Notes about this survey: to share this survey with others, please right click to copy this direct link address and paste it. Do not share the page to the survey once you've started it. If you navigate away from the survey, it should continue from where you left it, if you reopen the link in the same browser.
Return to the consultation.
To what extent do you agree or disagree with the proposal to introduce minimum service levels during strike action for inpatients already receiving hospital care? (optional) Please explain your position and provide any supporting evidence. (optional) Maximum 250 words.
To what extent do you agree or disagree with the proposal to introduce minimum service levels during strike action for existing patients requiring urgent elective treatment? (optional) For example priority 1 or priority 2 elective surgery lists, dialysis, elective caesarean, or induction of labour.
Please explain your position and provide any supporting evidence. (optional) Maximum 250 words.
To what extent do you agree or disagree with the proposal to introduce minimum service levels during strike action for existing patients needing emergency, critical or urgent assessments, diagnostics, or treatment? (optional) This does not include routine procedures like knee or hip replacements.
Please explain your position and provide any supporting evidence. (optional) Maximum 250 words.
To what extent do you agree or disagree with the proposal to introduce minimum service levels during strike action for new patients presenting to the hospital requiring unplanned assessments, diagnostics and/or treatment? (optional) Please explain your position and provide any supporting evidence. (optional) Maximum 250 words.
We propose that hospitals will treat people as they would on a non-strike day who require urgent or emergency treatment in hospital during the period of industrial action, and people who are receiving hospital care and are not yet well enough or able to be discharged. As such, the minimum service level that is required to ensure this treatment is delivered to patients in hospitals during strike action should be informed by expert clinical judgement, meaning the following sets of patients could expect to be treated as they would on a non-strike day:
inpatients already receiving hospital care existing patients requiring urgent elective treatment that would normally be delivered during the period of industrial action (for example: people on priority 1 or priority 2 elective surgery lists (surgery that is required within 72 hours for priority 1, or 4 weeks for priority 2), people requiring dialysis, transplant patients where a potential donor match is identified, elective caesarean or induction of labour) existing patients who could or will need emergency, critical or urgent assessment, diagnostics or treatment in hospital, (for example cancer or cardiac diagnostics and treatment, but not for example routine knee or hip replacement) new patients presenting to hospital that require unplanned assessment, diagnostics and/or treatment in hospital, (for example people presenting to emergency department, people in active labour)
To what extent do you agree or disagree with allowing local clinicians to determine whether their patients fall under the categories for the minimum service levels (MSL) outlined in the principles listed above during strike action? (optional) Please explain your position and provide any supporting evidence. (optional) Maximum 250 words.
NHS hospitals in Great Britain are operated by NHS trusts or health boards, who may sub-contract some of their work to other organisations. This may include cleaning or other support services being contracted to a private company; third-sector providers, such as social enterprises or charities, delivering some services; or other NHS organisations delivering services that support hospital treatments, including blood and transplant services which facilitate treatment requiring blood platelets or donated organs.
This means NHS trusts or health boards may not employ all the staff who are involved in the delivery of essential care provided by hospitals. In writing the MSL regulations the Secretary of State may specify the type of organisations the MSL applies to. This could limit the types of employers who are able to issue a work notice to ensure the continuity of essential hospital services during strike action.
If MSL regulations are introduced for hospital services, which types of employers do you think should be specified to follow these regulations during strike action? (optional) Please explain your position and provide any supporting evidence. (optional) Maximum 250 words.
We are proposing to introduce a minimum service level that would apply only to hospital care. This measure would not include health services available in the community such as pharmacies, GP surgeries and community health teams.
To what extent do you agree or disagree that MSLs should not include community-based health services? (optional) Please explain your position and provide any supporting evidence. (optional) Maximum 250 words.
Do you think there is an alternative option to introducing MSLs in hospitals, to ensure continuity of access to essential services and protect patients from risks to life and life-changing harm during strike action? (optional) Please explain your position and provide any supporting evidence. (optional) Maximum 250 words.
Were you, or anyone you know, in hospital or needed to go to hospital for any health-related reason on a day when you were aware that strike action was taking place?
Does your NHS trust or health board run a hospital that was affected by strike action since December 2022? (optional)
Acknowledging that precise figures may be unavailable, please provide your best estimate for the following questions.
Please provide an estimate of the total number of days that the hospital or hospitals you run were affected by strike action? (optional) Select the closest range.
How many hours did your NHS trust or health board managers and clinicians collectively spend preparing for the most recent period of strike action affecting your organisation? (optional) Select the closest range.
If you requested a derogation from a union to mitigate the impact of the most recent period of strike action, how many hours did NHS trust or health board managers and clinicians collectively spend on submitting the derogation request? (optional) Select the closest range.
How much do you estimate it cost your NHS trust or health board to continue to provide time-critical hospital services during the most recent period of strike action that affected your organisation? (optional) This may include, but is not limited to, expenses such as overtime payments. Please provide your best estimate and specify the types of costs included in your calculation. Maximum 250 words.
Based on the hospital MSL proposal outlined in the consultation document on GOV.UK, how would you compare the time commitment required for implementing this proposal to that of how you currently prepare for industrial action? (optional) Please explain your position and provide any supporting evidence. (optional) Maximum 250 words.
Do you anticipate incurring additional costs at the NHS trust or health board, either one-time or recurring, as a result of implementing a MSL for hospital-based services? (optional) Please explain your position and provide any supporting evidence. (optional) Maximum 250 words.
Has your trade union called industrial action in any NHS hospital since December 2022?
Provide an estimate for the total number of hours spent by your trade union officials to work with local hospital managers and national authorities such as NHS England, to ensure essential health services remained available during the most recent strike action your union was involved in. (optional) This includes but is not limited to discussions on special arrangements like derogations. Select the closest range.
Considering the proposal for a hospital MSL and the draft code of practice on reasonable steps trade unions should undertake, how do you anticipate the time commitment for your union officials to take these reasonable steps will compare to the time currently spent working with NHS trusts or health boards in preparation for industrial action? (optional) This includes but is not limited to discussions on special arrangements like derogations. Select the closest range.
Please explain your position and provide any supporting evidence. (optional) Maximum 250 words.
Do you anticipate that your trade union will incur new costs, either one-off or recurring, in implementing the reasonable steps as outlined in the draft code of practice? (optional) Please explain your position and provide any supporting evidence. (optional) Maximum 250 words.
Because you said you were in hospital or know someone who was in hospital during strike action, this question asks you about how industrial action in the NHS has impacted on your health or the health of people that you know.
Do you think that industrial action since December 2022 has affected your health or the health of someone you know? (optional) Please explain your answer. (optional) If you have a personal experience, please do not provide any detail that could identify yourself or other people, such as your name. Maximum 300 words.
Because you said you were employed as a member of staff during a period of strike action, this question asks you about how industrial action in the NHS impacted on people in your care whilst at work.
Do you think that industrial action since December 2022 affected the health of your patients? (optional) Please explain your answer. (optional) If you have a personal experience, please do not provide any detail that could identify yourself or other people, such as your name. Maximum 300 words.
The following questions asks for your organisation’s views on the impact of hospital strikes since December 2022 on patient health.
Which, if any, of the following patient categories do you think were affected by industrial action since December 2022? (optional) Patients with emergency and critical health needs
Patients with other time-critical health needs, for example dialysis, cancer care, maternity services, neo-natal, cardiac
Patients with non-emergency hospitalisations, for example medical wards, mental health in-patient care, diagnostics, discharge support, end of life care
Please explain your answer. (optional) If you have a personal experience, please do not provide any detail that could identify yourself or other people, such as your name. Maximum 300 words.
Do you believe there are groups of people, such as (but not limited to) those with protected characteristics, who would benefit from the proposed introduction of minimum service levels in some or all hospital services? (optional) Which groups do you think will benefit and why? (optional)
Do you believe there are groups of people, such as (but not limited to) those with protected characteristics, who would be negatively affected by the proposed introduction of minimum service levels in some or all hospital services? (optional) Which particular groups might be negatively affected and why? (optional)
The ‘review your answers’ feature lists all the questions that you have answered or had the opportunity to answer.
Clicking on the 'Change' button against an answer will allow you to amend that answer.
After making any amendments you can then click through the survey using the ‘Next’ button, previously answered questions retain their answers.
Hospital- based services – minimum service level Hospital-based services minimum service level proposal Impact of strike action for your trust or health board Impact of strike action for your trade union Impact of strike action in hospitals Impact of strike action in hospitals - member of staff Public sector equality duty (PSED)
We have a few questions we would like to ask to help us improve future consultations.
How satisfied are you with the consultation process? (optional) Do you think we could improve this process? (optional)
Thank you for completing the survey. If you would like to share it with others please use this link:
https://consultations.dhsc.gov.uk/6523d06284e26d0973066712
Return to the main GOV.UK page.
This survey is now closed.